1983 action in state or federal court

Free citation defense tips! Administrative citations website is about educating you to defend yourself against administrative citations. This is a law created in 1995 that permits cities and counties in California to fine you for just about anything (they appear to be used nationwide). This site was established because there is little self-help from any city on how to 'properly' oppose your citation. Lawyers that know this mysterious law are hard to find. These are 'punitive' citations that enrich your city. Basically it is a way of taxing you -- because a new tax will not pass. This is an attempt to bring together all the victims of administrative citations in the 540 local agencies within California (58 counties and 482 cities). Welcome to administrative citations.
admin
Site Admin
Posts: 125
Joined: Thu Sep 14, 2023 11:00 am

1983 action in state or federal court

Unread post by admin »

---
ALERT - A new federal opinion permits a party to file 1983 action without exhausting administrative remedies. See 1983 thread. (consult with your attorney) Jerry Jamgotchain; Theta Holding I, Inc., (Jamgotchian v. Ferraro)
---

If you or your counsel are knowledgeable you can bypass opposing your administrative citation in total. You can file a 1983 action because filing a 1983 action does not mandate exhaustion of administrative remedies.

Knick v. Tp. of Scott, Pennsylvania, 139 S. Ct. 2162 - Supreme Court 2019 (for you to review)

(it seems the Knick decision is rule of law when it comes to filing your 1983 action - and that is what the jamgotchian case is all about below)

Be certain to file your Tort Claims Form with the City. When they deny your claim, you can sue and collect.

However, if you do oppose the citation you may be screwed. At that point you may have to follow through all the way through trial and appeal. So, if you have been given a citation for a sign for example. It may violate your first amendment rights.

https://www.courtlistener.com/audio/87864/jerry-jamgotchian-v-gregory-ferraro/

This case has not concluded yet. It will offer good information.

Also check this case and the cases it cites.

Briggs v. City of Rolling Hills Estates, 40 Cal. App. 4th 637, 47 Cal. Rptr. 2d 29 (Ct. App. 1995).

While this may be a big deal for us, it is an annoyance for most courts.




More on all this later.
Locked